Rate That Game

[Sanjuro]

While I agree that 10/10 is sufficent as a rating, what he means by 11/10 is that the games rated this are in his opinion excellent so it isn't bad if he posted it as 11/10.

den_gale, FF7 and OOT are hardly the only games worthy of a 10/10 because there are many out there deserving of this rating.To be honest, half the people on GameWinners will tell you FF7 is hardly close to being perfect.In your opinion they may be but not everyone's, FF7 is a fine RPG yet hardly the best FF or RPG and OOT is a excellent Action/Adventure game(Possibly the best LOZ game).

While I loved Mischief Makers and Treasure make amazing games, there were many Treasure games that surpass MM.Did you get to play the import only Treasure's Sin and Punishment?It is truly excellent and one of the few worthy imports.

Jet Force Gemini was also a excellent game that is alot of fun, I just got another copy for only $2.00.

[Hex]

Getting a priceless game for two dollars? That's insane.

While I'm sure Treasure has many games better than Mischief Makers, I find the characters appealing and only have that one Treasure game (except for a few others I may not know are treasure games). Can't be too many.

I, like everyone else, forced myself to believe FF7 was completely awesome just because it was so good in its time. I'm a thinking 9 or 10 are much better now that I've realised that the only thing not overrated about FF7 is Tifa's...fighting ability. Yeah.

Isn't my Merco flavored account sexy?

[den_gale]

Originally Posted by Sanjuro

den_gale, FF7 and OOT are hardly the only games worthy of a 10/10 because there are many out there deserving of this rating.To be honest, half the people on GameWinners will tell you FF7 is hardly close to being perfect.In your opinion they may be but not everyone's, FF7 is a fine RPG yet hardly the best FF or RPG and OOT is a excellent Action/Adventure game(Possibly the best LOZ game).

Like I said: "IMO". I know perfectly well that what games are good is a verry pesonal matter. I was just writing that to show that, again IMO, a person should be carefull to rate a game 10/10 because it means that you think that it couldn't have been better.

[Paintballman88]

Originally Posted by den_gale

11/10? How can you rate a game 11/10, it goes with the rating "out of 10" there is no 11 if you have a selection of 10. If you like the game that much you give it a 10/10, and give other games lower rating. Not many games deserves 10/10. IMO: OoT and FFVII are the only games that deserve 10/10

last time i checked, ffVII is a playstation game, not n64

[den_gale]

I know that, if you read my post it was not to "rate that game", it was to illustrate that IMO, among all consoles and computers there are only two games that deserve full score.

[Sanjuro]

Treasure, has developed many games for alot of systems and all their games are worth checking out.Treaure used to make alot of games for Konami(Some of the best), they got sick of doing sequels and left Konami.They have never released sequels to their games until just 2004, Guardian Heroes recieved a sequel for the GBA and Gunstar Heroes is recieving a remake/redux for this year.
Here are a few Treasure games with platform that they are onWith a personal rating)

Ikaruga(GameCube in the U.S./Dreamcast in Japan)-Shooter (9)
Radiant Silvergun(Saturn in Japan)-Shooter (10)
Guadian Heroes(Saturn)-Action/RPG (10)
Guardian Heroes Advance(GBA)-Action/RPG (9)
Astro Boy:The Omega Factor(GBA)-Action/Shooter (10)
Stretch Panic(PS2) - Action (7)
Gunstar Heroes(Genesis) - Action (10)
Dynamite Headdy(Genesis/GameGear) - Platformer (9)
McDonald's Treasure Land(Genesis) - Platformer (8)
Sin and Punishment(N64 in Japan) - Shooter (10)
Silhoutte Mirage(PSOne in the U.S./Saturn in Japan) - Action (9)
Bangaio(N64 in Japan/Dreamcast in the U.S.) -Shooter (10)
Mischief Makers(N64) - Action/Platformer (9)
Light Crusader(Genesis) - Action/RPG (8)
Alien Soldier(Megadrive Japan only) - Action (10)
Rakugaki Show-time)PSONE Japan only) - Action (9)
Slipheed:The Lost Planet(PS2) - Shooter (6)
Gradius 5(PS2) - Shooter (9)
Wario World(GameCube) - Platformer (9)
Dragon Drive(GameCube Japan Only) - Action (8)
The Fighting(GBA Import only) - Action (7)
Tiny Toon Adventure:Buster's Bad Dream(GBA) - Action (8)

Treasure is working on a few other projects as well as Gunstar Super Heroes which is simply going to be amazing.Plus, as part of the Sega Ages series of PS2 games in Japan Treasure Box Gunstar Heroes is getting a updated version.Most of the Sega Ages don't get released here so hopefully we will recieve in the U.S.
People who will become Treasure worked on the following classic games:
Contra(NES) (10)
Super C(NES) (9)
Contra 3(SNES)(10)
Castlevania(NES) (10)
Axelay(SNES) (10)
Castlevania 4(SNES) (10)
and a few other titles.

den_gale, it is kind of sad that they only two games you can think of deserving a 10/10 is only FF7/OOT.There are vastly better games for the most part and equally solid games.

[kurt]

ssb - 8.5
re 2 - 8
golden eye -9
cbfd(conker bad fur day) -8.9
the new tetris - 6.9
and all pokemon games 0.1-3.5

[Excalibur310]

majoras mask owns. 10/10 i kno im a minority by saying i like it better than OoT but the whole story and the way it tied into OoT in a bizarre way drew me in. come on dont tell me u didnt get a tingly feeling at the end wen u see the skull kids drawing on the tree stump..lol

[kurt]

the thing with giving a game 10 out of 10 is that there is always better that u might not have seen like some of the games from japan

[GwJ]

SSBM-9.5
Papermario and the thousand year door-8.5
Conker's bad fur day- 11/10!!!!!!!!!
Mario Kart Double Dash/ 10

[den_gale]

Originally Posted by kurt

the thing with giving a game 10 out of 10 is that there is always better that u might not have seen like some of the games from japan

That is of course a fact and is why I said that rating a game 10 of 10 should almoast never be done, exept when you think a game is perfect.

There are alot of games that I give 9/10 that many probably would have given 10/10 if they mean what I mean about them.

[Jonny P]

I believe that the only 10/10 games on N 64 are Perfect Dark and the Ocarina Of Time. They are the only 2 games that I've played that made me wanna play them again and again even 10 years after they were made but i believe that Perfect Dark is better because you can play it any time and not have to start a new story. Alos I think that Perfect Dark and Mario Carts are by far the 2 best multi player games on the N 64. Other good 9/10 games are Super Mario 64, Goldeneye, Pokemon Stadium 2 and Mortal Kombat 4.

[den_gale]

Originally Posted by Jonny P

I believe that the only 10/10 games on N 64 are Perfect Dark and the Ocarina Of Time. They are the only 2 games that I've played that made me wanna play them again and again even 10 years after they were made but i believe that Perfect Dark is better because you can play it any time and not have to start a new story. Alos I think that Perfect Dark and Mario Carts are by far the 2 best multi player games on the N 64. Other good 9/10 games are Super Mario 64, Goldeneye, Pokemon Stadium 2 and Mortal Kombat 4.

I have to disagree with you on the PD part, it is not as good as Goldeneye. Though I look at it from multi-player point of view, PD has a better single player part, but Goldeneye 64 is the best multiplayer game I have ever played. I don't like to play single player 1PS that much.

[Fire King]

Only one game for the Nintendo 64 deserves 10/10 in my opinion, and that was OoT. (Famitsu gave it 40/40, which is very rare. It was a first back then.)

9/10 games:

Mischief Makers (Yeah I'm a fanboy and deal with it.)
Super Smash Bros. (Opened up an entirerly new genre of games)
Star Fox 64 (Same thing as above, almost)

8/10:

Super Mario 64 (Overrated in my opinion)
Majora's Mask (Same thing)
Mario Kart 64 (Eh)

[Sanjuro]

Out of the numerous games for the N64, these are the few that I feel deserve 10/10:

Legend of Zelda:OOT
Ogre Battle 64
Neon Genesis Evangelion(Import)
Resident Evil 2
Sin and Punishment(Import)

9-9.75 games:

Super Smash Brothers
Paper Mario
Conker's Bad Fur Day
Goldeneye
Perfect Dark
Mischief Makers
Hybrid Heaven
Pokemon Stadium 1 and 2
Blast Corps.
Pokemon Snap
Bomberman 64 1 and 2
Bomberman Hero
Star Soldier 64
Jet Force Gemini
Mario Tennis
Legend of Zelda:MM
Star Fox 64
Super Mario 64
Mario Kart 64
Banjo Kazooie/Tooie
Goemon's Great Adventure
Kirby 64
Yoshi's Story
Dr. Mario 64
Harvest Moon 64